Kuwait
The ITUC affiliate in Kuwait is the Kuwait Trade Union Federation (KTUF).
Kuwait ratified Convention No. 87 on Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise (1948) in 1961 and Convention No. 98 on the Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining (1949) in 2007.
Legal
Freedom of association / Right to organise
Freedom of association
The right to freedom of association is enshrined in the Constitution.
The right to freedom of association is recognised by law but strictly regulated.
Anti-Union discrimination
The law does not specifically protect workers from anti-union discrimination.
Barriers to the establishment of organisations
- Prior authorisation or approval by authorities required for the establishment of a union
- According to the 2010 Labour Code, the establishment of a trade union is subject to certification by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Labour. However, if the Minister fails to respond within 15 days of the petition to register the union shall be deemed to exist.
Restrictions on workers’ right to form and join organisations of their own choosing
- Single trade union system imposed by law and/or a system banning or limiting organising at a certain level (enterprise, industry and/or sector, regional and/or territorial, national)
- The 2010 Labour Code now allows for trade union pluralism at the grass-root level. However, it still restricts this right by providing that there can only be one general union.
Restrictions on trade unions’ right to organise their administration
- Restrictions on the right to freely draw up their constitutions and rules
- The Labour Law of 2010 provides that trade union organizations are "free to be guided" by the model regulations issued by the Ministerial Order. The Public Authority for Manpower issued a number of guiding rules for organizations to follow in the formulation of their constitutions and regulations.
- Restrictions on the right to elect representatives and self-administer in full freedom
- Section 108 of the Labour Law provides for the possibility to dismiss an organization’s board of directors by court order in case the board engages in an activity that either violates the provisions of the Labour Law or of the “laws relevant to the preservation of public order and morals”.
- Restrictions on the right to freely organise activities and formulate programmes
- Trade unions may not engage in political activity or activities involving religious or sectarian matters. Furthermore, trade unions are prohibited from investing in financial or real state speculations and from accepting gifts and donations without approval by the Ministry.
- Administrative authorities’ power to unilaterally dissolve, suspend or de-register trade union organisations
- The courts can dissolve any union that violates the labour laws or threatens public order and morality.
Categories of workers prohibited or limited from forming or joining a union, or from holding a union office
- Other civil servants and public employees
- Government employees are seemingly denied the right to organise as they are excluded from the scope of the 2010 Labour Code, and as the special law governing their status does not contain any provision in this regard.
- Non-national or migrant workers
- The 2010 Labour Code provides that only Kuwaiti workers enjoy the right to join a trade union and to participate in its activities.
- Domestic workers
- Domestic workers are excluded from the 2010 Labour Code.
Right to collective bargaining
Right to collective bargaining
The right to collective bargaining is recognised by law.
Restrictions on the principle of free and voluntary bargaining
- Compulsory conciliation and / or binding arbitration procedure in the event of disputes during collective bargaining, other than in essential services
- In the event of a collective dispute, the parties have to resort to a long procedure that involves direct negotiations, a Reconciliation Committee and eventually an Arbitration Panel. The decision rendered by the Arbitration Panel is final and has the same effect as that of an Appeal Tribunal. The law also grants the Ministry concerned the right to intervene in order to settle the dispute amicably.
Restrictions on the scope of application and legal effectiveness of concluded collective agreements
- Authorities’ approval of freely concluded collective agreements
- A collective agreement will be effective subject to registration with the concerned Ministry and its publication in the Official Gazette. The law grants the Ministry the authority to object to the conditions agreed if it deems that the agreement violates the law.
Limitations or ban on collective bargaining in certain sectors
- Other categories
- Domestic workers and migrant workers do not have the right to bargain collectively.
Right to strike
Right to strike
The right to strike is recognised by law but strictly regulated.
Barriers to lawful strike actions
- Compulsory recourse to arbitration, or to long and complex conciliation and mediation procedures prior to strike actions
- Sections 131 and 132 of the Labour Law grant intervention powers to the Minister in a case of a collective dispute. He is allowed, without being asked to do so by any of the disputing parties, to bring about an amicable settlement of the dispute, and may also refer the dispute to the Conciliation Committee or the Arbitration Panel, as it deems appropriate.
Undermining of the recourse to strike actions or their effectiveness
- Absence of specific protection for workers involved in lawful strike actions (e.g. against dismissal)
- There is no protection for strikers against retribution by the state.
In practice
The Manpower Authority signed an agreement binding the Kuwait National Petroleum Company and the trade union of the Kuwait National Petroleum Company without the presence of the legitimate representatives of the union. Ammar Al-Ajmi, the union Chairman, condemned this practice, which constitutes a blatant interference of the public authority in collective bargaining, and he added that they would file a case before the Attorney General to stop these practices.
Asian migrant workers who had staged a protest to demand the payment of outstanding wages were arrested by the police and detained at the station. The detained workers explained that protesting was their last resort to push the company to pay wage arrears. However, the company filed a complaint against them for absence without leave. Workers were also threatened with deportation.
Despite the introduction of a new law on 24 June 2015, the right to form or join a union is still denied, workers keep being employed under the kafala system of visa sponsorship and abuses continue to occur in the Gulf country. Despite the recently approved law banning passport confiscation, this practice continues in practice. Moreover, the kafala system continues to be intact and workers still cannot change jobs without the consent of their employer. Under this system, domestic workers who leave their jobs before the end of their contract without their sponsor’s consent are considered to have “absconded,” a crime under Kuwaiti law. They can be arbitrarily detained, fined or sentenced to imprisonment.
In this respect, the situation of exploitation and denial of the most basic human and working rights of Kuwaiti domestic workers is more relevant than ever. On 31 March 2017, newspapers worldwide reported the case of an Ethiopian domestic worker who fell from the 7th floor and her employer filmed the whole scene without intervening to help. The Kuwaiti employer filmed the domestic worker who landed on a metal awning and survived, then posted the incident on social media and declared to police that the lady was attempting suicide. However, the domestic worker stated that she was trying to save herself from the employer who was attempting to kill her and that she fell out of the window while trying to escape. This is only one of numerous cases registered in the recent past. Another example occurred on 6 March 2017 when a couple was arrested for torturing their domestic worker, imprisoning her in their home and depriving her of food until she managed to escape and to seek help. This situation is so common that the Government has set up shelters for them while some seek help from their embassies.
The Oil and Petrochemical Industries Workers Confederation (OPIWC), representing workers at state-owned oil, gas and petrochemical companies, began negotiations with the KPC and the acting oil minister to prevent the implementation of the Strategic Alternative Pay Scale. The union also sought the establishment of a joint committee to ensure full consultation over any changes to legislation and to seek assurances that the oil sector would be exempt from the Strategic Alternative bill.
Negotiations broke down, however, and the oil workers’ unions announced they would go on strike from 17 April. The strike affected five state-owned companies, the Kuwait National Petroleum Company (KNPC), a subsidiary of KPC, Kuwait Oil Company, Kuwait Oil Tanker Company, Equate Petrochemical Industries Company and Kuwait Gulf Oil Company.
As promised the National Guard was brought in to “protect” the oil plants and ensure they kept functioning, and KNPC appealed to Egypt and India to provide technical staff to keep production at its plants going during the strike. Meanwhile, the government asked the relevant authorities to take legal action against the strike, which it considered illegal, and bring those involved to account.
The strike was suspended after three days when OPIWC met the Prime Minister to ask for a mechanism to discuss the workers’ demands. A tripartite committee composed of the cabinet, the state-owned Kuwait Petroleum Corporation (KPC) and OPIWC was formed, negotiations with the unions on their demands were assured and guarantees were given that no striking workers would be sanctioned. Negotiations were successfully concluded on 24 May 2016 with a 7.5 per cent pay rise for oil workers.
The unions representing Kuwait’s oil workers were not consulted when a new pay scale was introduced. In the first quarter of 2016 the Government of Kuwait prepared a new draft law for public sector jobs called the Strategic Alternative Salary Scale. The law included measures to reduce government costs by “harmonising” pay. Oil workers are covered by separate labour legislation and should have been exempt from the new plan. The state-owned Kuwait Petroleum Corporation (KPC) decided however to unilaterally impose the new plan and issued new regulations without consultation with the unions. The new regulations entailed cuts in oil workers’ wages and an end to longstanding benefits.
The oil workers’ unions urged the company and the government to withdraw the plan, and threatened to strike if it did not do so. The response of KPC was to announce that it would continue with its ‘rationalisation’ programme, including the reduction in salaries, benefits and other incentives to staff, and that it had a strategic plan ready to face any strikes. It said that the National Guard and oil facilities security staff would be used to run operations in the event of a strike, specialist workers would be brought in from other countries, and striking employees would be penalised.
Article 104 of the Labour Act prohibits unions from interfering in political, religious and sectarian issues. Ministry of Justice Workers Union Chairperson Ahmad Al-Mutairi warned that unions would engage in civil disobedience if the government went ahead with its plan to activate Article 104. Al-Mutairi warned that all public utilities would be disrupted if the government dissolved any union.
The Kuwait Trade Union Federation (KTUF) has called for national dialogue to address the growing crisis in the country between various segments of society. Political opposition has attempted to mobilise around the jailing of three former MPs for three years for insulting the Emir. Labour unions have rejected calls for demonstrations launched by the opposition.
In May 2013, around 80 per cent of the workers employed at the Oil Sector Services Co, owned by Kuwait Petroleum Corporation participated in a strike led by the Kuwait, the Oil & Petrochemical Industries Workers Confederation. After exhausting all remedies of negotiating higher wages, more than 1,000 workers decided to take strike action. The company attempted to break the strike by sending individual letters to workers and threatening them with forced transfers, salary deductions and dismissal. Nevertheless, the strike continued for four days and management acceded to worker demands.
In February 2013, around 100 cleaning workers employed at the Ministry of Social Affairs and Labour’s social care homes staged a strike at the Social Care Compound in Ghernatah demanding an increase in their monthly pay from KD60 (160 EUR) to KD100 (260 EUR). Moreover, workers stated they were forced to pay KD100 for each annual leave request. The Bangladeshi embassy, at the request of the Ministry of Social Affairs and Labour, visited workers individually and told them they could be deported for strike action. On the day of the strike, management called police who broke up the strike by threatening workers.
Threats to terminate workers for participating in union activities were made by the chief of the highest legislative body of the Kuwaiti Government. In March 2012, a senior state official, Al-Saraawi, head of the Religious Edict and Legislation Department, suggested that protesting workers from the Customs Department and Kuwait Airways be dismissed en masse for participating in a week long work stoppage. Al-Saraawi stated that the government may take disciplinary measures against workers whose strike has a negative impact on the interests of the public. Abdurrahman Al-Sumait, Head of the National Union of Kuwait Workers and Employees, expressed his disappointment at the statements which violate international obligations signed by Kuwait.
Strikes are increasing despite being only officially allowed in the private sector, which is not organised, is very small and is mostly composed of some 1.7 million foreigners. 2011 saw an unprecedented wave of strikes and industrial action in the public sector, which employs close to 80% of the 360,000-strong workforce of Kuwaiti nationals after state oil sector workers managed to negotiate pay rises of up to 66% from the state. Since then, employees of several ministries and public sector institutions have lobbied for better salaries and benefits - customs officials, port workers, and staff at the Ministries of the Interior, Health and Social Affairs and Labour all started mass walkouts in protest against poor salaries and benefits. The strike action also affected the Kuwait airlines where 5,000 employees are facing a proposed privatisation process. Although the Kuwaiti employees were planning strike action, foreign employees were being advised to continue working as they are more vulnerable to being sacked without notice during a strike.
In September, around 850 Kuwaiti port workers began daily two hour strikes over wages, disrupting operations at three commercial ports. On 25 October the government agreed to raise wages following a short strike organised by the 4,000-strong KAC Workers Union that grounded half of the airline’s fleet. In early October, workers from the Kuwait Stock Exchange called off a planned 19 October strike after reaching an agreement with the government over money owed. The dispute centered on bonus payments and the impending transfer of employees from the bourse to a newly formed Capital Markets Authority (CMA). The Kuwait University’s academic society also planned a demonstration on 26 October over salary increases.
Government officials in Kuwait have repeatedly told striking workers they would not consider any demands while walkouts are taking place. In October, the government announced it was planning a new law which would punish striking civil servants and restrict strike action. In response to the strike wave on 17 October the Foreign Minister tendered his resignation, while at least one other Minister was believed to be considering resigning as well. On 19 December the Kuwait Trade Union Federation held a demonstration outside the Civil Service Ministry following a statement by Justice Minister Ahmed Al Mulaifi that strikes are prohibited and that international conventions which guarantee workers’ rights are not applicable to him. The statement was in response to strike action being undertaken by employees in the Justice Ministry itself. The workers had also complained over pressure on non-qualified expatriates to work in the ministry instead of citizens as well as issues relating to retirement. Unionists from the Oil Workers’ Union and Kuwait Oil Tankers Workers’ Union also attended the protests to show solidarity.
Some 200 employees of the Ministry of Communications held a demonstration on 19 September at the headquarters of the Union of Kuwait Government Sector Workers, calling for the dissolution of the board of directors of the union and an urgent general meeting to elect a new board. They complained the current board of directors had for many years taken over the union, deferring the appointment of new members. The workers criticised the board for poor reporting to members and for declining to register other ministry workers as members of the union. The current board of directors has also reportedly hindered workers from joining the union, and there have been no new members for seven years.
In August 45 Filipinas employed as beauticians in Kuwait ran away from their employer, whom they accused of illegal recruitment, unfair labour practices, and physical and sexual abuse. One of three workers reportedly deported from Kuwait due to their role in the protest said to media that they had been told by labour officials that they were not entitled to any assistance since they were not legitimate migrant workers. Officials investigating the incident merely stated that all but three decided to go back to work the next day.
Bus drivers from the Kuwait Public Transport Company went on strike in August over non payment of a promised allowance and deduction in the salaries of some 2,900 workers. 88 drivers were reportedly dismissed during the strike, but calls were made for their reinstatement.
In March, in response to a threatened strike by the Kuwait Ports Foundation Workers’ Union, the Kuwaiti Council of Ministers held an emergency meeting during which it decided to take legal action to prevent the strike from going ahead despite the union’s legal right to take action. The union, which represents 930 members employed by the state-owned Kuwait Ports Foundation, has attempted to enter into negotiations with managers for the past two years to discuss the fact that staff benefits and career development structures have not been reviewed since the 1970s.
The single trade union system continues to exist. However, despite the trade union monopoly imposed by law, some trade unions exist outside the Kuwait Trade Union Federation (KTUF), such as the Bank Workers’ Union and the Kuwait Airways Workers’ Union. In practice, reports indicate that foreign workers have joined trade unions before they have worked in the country for the statutory five years. However, less than 5% of the unionised workforce is foreign. Migrant workers remain vulnerable to abuse and retribution if they protest poor working conditions.